James Roosevelt Bayley (1853-1872)
Michael Augustine Corrigan (1873-1880)
Winand Wigger (1881-1901)
John Joseph O'Connor (1901-1927)
Thomas J. Walsh (1928-1952)
Thomas A. Boland (1953-1974)
Peter L. Gerety (1974-1986)
Theodore Cardinal McCarrick (1986-2000)
John J. Myers (2001-2016)
Joseph W. Tobin (2016-present)